Guwahati  
 
logo
  Guwahati,
North East »» India developing NE states’ infrastructure: Defence secretary•••Bid to check influx in Manipur•••Gangmei demands apology from BJP•••State »» ’Sarania Kachari people should be united so that the community can develop’•••Blow to AGP, three leaders arrested•••Compensation sought for villagers•••National »» AAP confident, BJP hopeful, Congress despondent post election•••’BJP will win by comfortable majority’•••’Matter of concern if exit polls come true’•••International »» Crack down on terrorists, daily tells Pakistan•••’Unipolar world unacceptable to Russia’•••’Better no nuclear deal than a bad one’•••    
  Home » Op-Ed » Story
 
Faith stifles free speech in India
 

B oth Hindu and Muslim fanatics are up in arms against artistic and literary freedom in India. One of their targets is the old “sinner” Salman Rushdie. But there are two others.

One of them is social scientist Ashis Nandy, who stirred a hornet’s nest by saying at the Jaipur Literature Festival that most of the corrupt people in the country happened to be from the lower castes (he said this in a certain context that was ignored). It is a slur which champions of these communities can hardly ignore if only because their entire political career is based on promoting caste consciousness that fuels antipathy towards the upper castes.

Foremost among them is Dalit czarina Mayawati, whose slogan at one time was: “Tilak, tarazu aur talwar, inko maro jootey char.” It meant beat with shoes the Brahmins (who wear ‘tilak’ on their foreheads), Banias (who weigh the goods in their shops with ‘tarazu’ or pair of scales) and Kshatriyas (the warrior class who sport ‘talwar’ or sword and hold second place after Brahmins in caste hierarchy).

Mayawati’s demand was that Nandy be arrested forthwith under an act which seeks to protect Dalits and adivasis (tribals) from atrocities.

What she did not care to consider was whether the law, meant to safeguard these communities from a continuation of the centuries–old social denigration, could be applied to a scholarly thesis. It has to be noted that the person mentioned by Nandy in this context was former Jharkhand chief minister Madhu Koda, a tribal, who is now in jail on charges of corruption.

The point, however, is not about who is right and who is wrong. It is about whether a renowned sociologist has the right to express an opinion based on his study of the social and political scene – or whether he should be put in jail for saying what he believes to be correct.

Nandy is not the first academic, of course, who has to confront the bigots. Not long ago, the Oriental Research Institute in Pune was vandalised because historian James W Laine had worked there while preparing a biography of Shivaji, which was not liked by the present–day admirers of the Maharashtrian warrior.

Arguably, if vandals and intemperate politicians are having a free run in the matter of intimidating those holding contrarian views in their opinion, the reason is that the governments at both the centre and in the states have tended to yield ground to the extremists. One notable instance of such a retreat was the banning of Rushdie’s novel, “The Satanic Verses”, by the Rajiv Gandhi government in 1988 under pressure from Muslim hardliners. The fact that the kowtowing did not satisfy them is, however, evident from Rushdie’s decision to stay away from the Jaipur Literature Festival last year because of the government’s reluctance to guarantee him protection.

And this year too, he had to call off a visit to Kolkata for the same reason along with filmmaker Deepa Mehta in connection with the release of “Midnight’s Children”, a film based on his Booker prize–winning book of the same name.

The government did not even allow the film to be shot in India for fear of offending fundamentalists. As a result, Mehta had to shoot the film in Sri Lanka. Another film, which is having to run the gauntlet of the Muslim militants is Kamal Haasan’s “Vishwaroopam” even though it shows an Indian Muslim intelligence officer battling Islamic fanatics in Afghanistan and should be a matter of pride therefore for “patriotic” Muslims, as Haasan said.

The standard explanation given by the Muslim radicals for lambasting Rushdie or Haasan is that they have hurt the community’s religious sentiments.

It is the same argument which compelled Galileo to deny in the 17th century that the earth moved round the sun since his claim was found hurtful to their beliefs by Christians at the time. It took the Catholic church three centuries to offer a formal apology for its denunciation of the astronomer.

Yet, this argument is offered time and again in 21st century India to satisfy the prejudices of the diehards. In view of the difficulties which his film faces, Haasan has even said that he may have to seek refuge in a secular country just as painter M.F. Husain had to flee from India and die in exile because of the threat posed by Hindu storm–troopers. Regrettably, it is no secret that the silent majority of Hindus and Muslims do not subscribe to the irrationalism of the fanatics.

Yet, the government is reluctant to act against the trouble–makers in case it is seen to be directed against the community as a whole.

Interestingly, the Marxists are no better despite their claim to be progressive, for it was when they were in power in West Bengal that the controversial Bangladeshi author, Taslima Nasreen, had to leave Kolkata because of the disturbances caused by a minor Muslim outfit.

There is little doubt that the decline of the Congress and the growth of backward–looking parties based on specific castes and communities are responsible for the prevailing cultural terrorism.

Amulya Ganguli


.
       
Maximum
 
Minimum
 
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
 Arunachal News
Be partners in development for peace: Tuki to people
Excited villagers trek for days to participate in district inauguration
Aalo Forest Festival under way
Dirang all set to break hydel fiasco jinx
 Meghalaya News
Feb 11 deadline for transporting extracted coal
JHADC removes Nepali ’Rangbah Shnong’
 Northeast News
India developing NE states’ infrastructure: Defence secretary
Bid to check influx in Manipur
Gangmei demands apology from BJP
UNC condemns blast
 Cachar News
Technical advances making cancer treatment easier: Dr Rath
ACKHSA pays homage to Prof Ramendu Bhattacharjee
 National News
AAP confident, BJP hopeful, Congress despondent post election
’BJP will win by comfortable majority’
’Matter of concern if exit polls come true’
Manjhi meets PM, says will not resign
 International News
Crack down on terrorists, daily tells Pakistan
’Unipolar world unacceptable to Russia’
’Better no nuclear deal than a bad one’
Australian PM calls early meeting
 State-1
’Sarania Kachari people should be united so that the community can develop’
Blow to AGP, three leaders arrested
Compensation sought for villagers
Voting suspended in three wards of Dimou
 State-2
Union Minister inaugurates CSR Hub at IIE
Kaziranga to be promoted as a birding destination
Religious tourism to be promoted in Majuli: Uma Bharti
BJP charges Congress of rule violation
 Local Sports
Assam restrict Kerala at 266
Website for Bodoland Indigenous Games Association launched
 Sports
Australia hammer India by 106 runs
Glad to end run drought: Dhawan
Omission of Pollard, Bravo huge loss for Windies: Holder
BCCI AGM, polls on March 2
 Editorial
Saradha lesson ignored as Chit Funds operate freely
Indian ’Highfliers’ set to boost student numbers in US
US firm offers Sahara three options – with a threat
Letters to the Editor
 Op-Ed (Sunday)
Financial Inclusion: The Way Ahead
Rajan puts onus of recovery on union budget
The Middle Way
 
Assam
 
Assam is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Dispur located in the city of Guwahati.
 
more...
Nagaland
 
Nagaland is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Kohima. located in the Guwahati city.
 
more...
Mizoram
 
Mizoram is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Aizwal. located in the Guwahati city.
 
more...
Meghalaya
 
Meghalaya is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Shillong. located in the Guwahati.
 
more...
Manipur
 
Manipur is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Imphal.
 
more...
Tripura
 
Tripura is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Agartala.
 
more...
Arunachal Pradesh
 
Arunachal Pradesh is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Itanagar.
 
more...
Sikkim
 
Sikkim is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Gangtok.
 
more...
Home  |  Guwahati City  |  Editorial  |  International  |  National  |  Business  |  Arunachal  |  Meghalaya   |  Northeast  |  State  |  Cachar  |  Sports   |  Local Sports
 Archive  |  Melange  |  Saturday Fare  |  Junior Sentinel  |  Multilingual  |  About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Advertise with us  |  Dongmusa

The next morning, when the 646-206 car came to office uncle sitting area, Natsuki books already 70-177 buried under a pot of tea companion. The louis vuitton replica handbags train is Robes de bal traveling on the Rhine River, the railway line side is the hermes replica handbags beautiful Rhine, one side is the lush vegetation of 70-411 the Black Forest, when there is the mulberry replica handbags castle looming hills ysl replica handbags or woods replica handbags around their replica handbags long history, unique shape, each one has its own vivid story those 70-480 strip banner spire on Microsoft 70-410 the windward dancing, which makes clear that they louis vuitton replica handbags are still fresh vitality.