Begin typing your search above and press return to search.

Backtracking RSS leaves BJP high and dry

Sentinel Digital DeskBy : Sentinel Digital Desk

  |  3 April 2016 12:00 AM GMT

By Amulya Ganguli

The beauty of an open society is that its air of freedom has a calming effect on fundamentalists. They soon realise that their chest-thumping display of seemingly potent sentiments not only fails to impress for long, but even causes amusement after a while.

What was initially perceived, therefore, by the Bharatiya Jata Party (BJP) as a surefire recipe for success has subsequently turned out to be a damp squib.

It is probably such a realisation about the limited shelf-life of provocative endeavours which persuaded the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) chief, Mohan Bhagwat, to make a u-turn on his suggestion for encouraging the young to chant “Bharat Mata ki Jai”.

Since coercion is antithetical to democracy, the powers-that-be in the saffron brotherhood must have mulled over the counterproductive ture of an attempt to push a slogan down the people’s throats.

The BJP, therefore, has lost its much-vaunted patriotic card. Moreover, it may not be a coincidence that the retreat by the RSS followed its disapproval of Parliamentary Affairs Minister Venkaiah idu’s praise for rendra Modi as “God’s gift to India”.

The sigl from gpur, the RSS headquarters, can be interpreted as one favouring discernible achievements in governce rather than depending on emotive slogans and promoting a persolity cult.

Notwithstanding the parivar’s monopolistic claim on tiolism, it probably has begun to differentiate between its own brand of the credo and xenophobia.

The awareness that ultra-tiolism can degenerate into hooliganism - as was evident in the assault by BJP sympathisers among lawyers on JNUSU president Kanhaiya Kumar - may have played a part in persuading the RSS to take a step back.

Although the initial target of the RSS was youth, the BJP interpreted the call to chant the slogan as a diktat for everyone. Venkaiah idu said, therefore, that no one had the right to decline to say it.

Hence, the decision of the BJP, the Shiv Se and even the supposedly secular Congress and the tiolist Congress Party (NCP) to suspend a member of the Maharashtra assembly for refusing to say “Bharat Mata ki Jai”. There is little doubt that the next few days will see a great deal of backtracking by those who tried to be more loyal than the king.

While the BJP’s somersaults will be amusing to watch, the party with a lot of egg on its face is the Congress which tried to emulate the BJP’s tiolism in the hope that it will be able to garner some Hindu votes.

Now that the RSS chief has said that no one should be forced to say the slogan, the Congress will be in a quandary, for the episode has once again exposed the fact that it no longer adheres to secularism, or any other ideology for that matter.

It meanders along under an inept leadership with no principles to guide the party. All that is of interest to the doddering 131-year-old organisation is whatever ploy will help it to grab power even if it is palpably opportunistic.

It is the same with the NCP - or the “turally corrupt party”, as Modi once called it - if only because its members come from the same stable of the Congress comprising time-servers.

For the BJP, the question will be: why did the RSS leave it high and dry after providing it with a slogan which the party thought would help its electoral cause.

Moreover, the patriotic card was expected to counter the “anti-tiols” among the student community in the JNU, the Hyderabad Central University and elsewhere.

Now, the ultra-Left and the jehadi elements in these institutions, as Fince Minister Arun Jaitley has alleged, will not be as much under pressure from the closet saffronites among the university officials as before.

However, what the short-lived “Bharat Mata ki Jai” episode has underlined is the fundamental difference between the BJP and other parties - the fact that the latter do not want to impose their writ on the country.

Yet, this is exactly what the BJP has been reflexively trying to do since its assumption of office at the centre in 2014.

While the planting of party faithful in various “autonomous” institutions like the Indian Council of Historical Research or the Film and Television Institute or the tiol Book Trust is in line with what is followed by all ruling parties, what has come to the fore is the BJP’s objective of moulding the country in its own saffron image. The “Bharat Mata ki Jai” tactic was the latest endeavour in this respect.

But good sense has prevailed with the country’s tolerant multicultural tenets exorcising authoritarian tendencies.

It is to be hoped that this evidence of moderation, emating from the RSS, is strengthened with a firm admonition from gpur and New Delhi to the extremists in the saffron ranks to remain within the bounds of the law.

Mercifully, some of them, like Yogi Adityath and Sakshi Maharaj, have been silenced either by Modi via BJP president Amit Shah or the RSS.

But there are others like the followers of the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parisahd (ABVP), the parivar’s student wing, who have vowed to prevent their bete noire, Kanhaiya Kumar, from entering Aligarh to deliver a lecture. It is for the police to enforce such restrictions, not vigilante groups.

(Amulya Ganguli is a political alyst. The views expressed are persol. He can be reached at

Next Story
Jobs in Assam
Jobs in Rest of NE
Top Headlines
Assam News